Skip to contentSkip to navigation
CEO tells competitors to stop attacks against CBC by Dylan Robertson
Media Monitor
Media Monitor - Terms and Conditions

Media Monitor is Canada's leading database for news stories on the broadcasting system, media ownership and cultural policies in Canada. The purpose of this database is to collect and preserve news stories relating to these issues, without modification, so that the public may, without cost, access the database for the purposes of scholarship, research, private study and related purposes.

One example of fair dealing is downloading a single copy of an article or part of an article for your own research or private study. The materials on this database are protected by the Canadian Copyright Act, and apart from the exercise of fair user rights, no unauthorized use or reproduction is permitted without the consent of the copyright owners. If you are willing to restrict your use of this database to the uses permitted by the Canadian Copyright Act, then please click Accept below.

CEO tells competitors to stop attacks against CBC by Dylan Robertson

Written by
Winnipeg Free Press
Published by
Winnipeg Free Press
on
October 31st, 2018

The head of the CBC is telling private-market competitors to back off on attacks against the public broadcaster, saying media need to collaborate on news to undercut the rise of misinformation.

The head of the CBC is telling private-market competitors to back off on attacks against the public broadcaster, saying media need to collaborate on news to undercut the rise of misinformation.

"Attacking each other is not a solution," said Catherine Tait, president and CEO of both CBC and Radio-Canada. "In order to ensure trust, we must work together."

She also said the CBC might change its peculiar accounting practices, which obfuscate how much taxpayer cash goes to digital offerings.

In a keynote speech at an Ottawa telecommunications conference, Tait said media ought to collaborate to prevent fake news and disinformation from shaking Canadian politics.

She did not offer specifics, but told reporters that CBC could "share resources" with its competitors instead of "sending out seven trucks to the same location" for simple press conferences.

"I think we're all realizing that the days of straight-up competition in the domestic market simply don't make economic sense," she said.

Tait told the conference Canadians should subscribe to newspapers. She similarly asked Parliament to close a loophole that allows Canadian businesses to write off advertising on social-media platforms — one that has undermined Canadian media organizations.

"We all have financial challenges, but it's not public broadcasting that is hurting private media in Canada. Making the public broadcaster smaller or weaker won't stop the Googles and Facebooks of the world, or the spread of disinformation," she said.

Tait’s remarks come just days after a torrent of criticism over the CBC’s decision to air murder mysteries and baking shows on television instead of municipal election coverage, opting for radio broadcasts and live coverage on social media.

The 1991 Broadcasting Act says the network's mandate is to "provide radio and television services" that reflect the country, but that CBC "programming" should "be made available throughout Canada by the most appropriate and efficient means and as resources become available for the purpose."

That’s led critics to insist the CBC has no business moving its duty to inform off of conventional broadcasting, while Tait and others say the network ought to focus on online offerings to reach more Canadians.

In September 2016 testimony to Parliament, the founder of the site iPolitics, James Baxter, called the CBC "an uber-predator" for putting the bulk of its resources in markets that are already competitive, producing free news that leaves "a profoundly chilling effect" on upstarts trying to charge for content.

After her speech, Tait said she’d be open to having the CBC provide more transparency over how it uses its annual $1.2 billion of taxpayer cash.

She noted that the CRTC just renewed its licence, and on the next renewal — scheduled five years from now — she would provide more data if the regulator asked CBC to do so.

"We really respond to the CRTC requirements and we'll look at that for sure. And there's a lot of interest in looking at digital," she told the Free Press.

Canadian law only compels broadcasters to report their spending for radio and television programming, not their online offerings. Meanwhile, the CBC reports its spending on two separate timelines, receiving its funding on fiscal years starting in April, and reporting its spending to the CRTC each August.

Comparing each 2017 figure shows that $209 million of the parliamentary stipend isn't accounted for in either the radio or TV spending reported four months later. Critics believe that means the network spent that much money on digital services.

But Carleton University communications Prof. Dwayne Winseck cautions that the two numbers can’t be directly compared, because of the four-month summer gap which can include major broadcasting events like the Olympics.

He sees a lack of transparency in the CBC’s budgeting. "The CBC has historically and recently been notoriously bad at this, which really cuts against the grain of them being a good, public-service media provider," Winseck said.

Similarly, the CBC reported a drop of 1,100 full-time staff working in television from 2016 to 2017, but a 342 increase in overall employees. That makes it unclear if the CBC has more than a thousand employees dedicated to online content.

Speaking generally, Tait noted that CBC reporters often file content used for radio, television and online reports. "We approach our news as multi-platform."

© Winnipeg Free Press